In the realm of video games, few publications can boast the longevity and dedication of Nintendo Life, which has been reviewing and celebrating the medium for over two decades. With a repository of over 7,500 reviews, the site has awarded 10/10 scores to 69 games, an average of just under 3.5 'Outstanding' games per year. This article takes a deep dive into the history of these 10/10 scores, exploring the games that have earned the highest praise and the criteria that define them. From the classic Marios and Zeldas to the innovative and boundary-pushing titles, each game on this list has left an indelible mark on the gaming landscape. But what makes a game truly 'Outstanding'? And how has the bar for excellence evolved over the years? As we reflect on the past, we also look forward, considering the future of gaming and the potential for new 10/10 experiences. Join me as I explore the history, the criteria, and the future of the 10/10 score, and reflect on the games that have earned the highest praise in the world of video games.